You were the boy who said he loved me
You were the first to say be who you can be
The first time we met you could barely speak
I can't believe I thought you were for me

Cause laughs are turned to cries
and truths are turned to lies
and my memories divide
between the bad and the shy

I saw a guy who was shy and sweet
I saw the person I wanted you to be
I can't remember why I couldn't see the truth
But it's too late and things aren't as they should

Cause laughs were turned to cries
and truths were turned to lies
and my memories divide
between the bad and the shy

I miss the shy
I miss the laughs that we shared
I miss the times
when I really thought you cares
but now it doesn't matter and I'm left wondering

When our laughs were turned to cries
and the truth was turned to lies
how did my memories divide
between this guy and the shy